It was something many people were looking forward to, and I must admit, it was nice to have everyone else coming to Aberdeen for a change, rather than always going somewhere else.
In any case, my family and I had a little drink at my flat, then we went out for dinner at Wagamamas, before heading up to the pub across the road from the concert hall. The whole place was very busy, since the AUSA Torcher parade was also on at the same time.
We went in and sat down at half past seven, in this beautiful music hall. Then Bucksburn struck up and the concert started. In each half, Bucksburn, then SLOT played.
Unfortunately, I don't think the room is at all geared up for pipe bands. There was a hideous echo where we were sitting, though I don't think my ringing, sore ears was all due to the building. It took until the second half before I realised that it actually sounded good when Bucksburn were on stage. Sure it was loud, and echo-ey (though from what my dad said the echo was much better at the back where the sound man was -pumping up the volume *sigh*), but the ensemble was there. It sounded good.
But when SLOT was on - man my ears were sore. The huge crack of side drummers absolutely battering away at sharp side drums, unendingly slightly ahead of the rest of the music, the echo filling the room with undefinable sound, so loud that I heard more than a few people complaining that they couldn't even hear the pipes, since the drumming was so off-putting. Why the need to batter it so hard? Surely it's harder to play the complex stuff anyway if your hands are moving so far off the drum with each hit? The drum kit was as bad, as it was actually mic-ed up. When the poor fiddle player was playing, you couldn't hear a thing. By the time it was half-way through their part in the second half, I had my hands covering my ears and was exceptionally close to walking out in the middle of the set. Not what you expect from a group of recent world champions.
And the continuous tuning. It always seemed to me rather unprofessional to tune on stage. But to be honest, the piping was, when we could hear it over the drums, pretty good.
I feel kind of sorry for Bucksburn and for the pipers of SLOT. For most of the people who were unimpressed, (I even heard one person say he would never go to another band concert) it was because of the drumming, and the awful ensemble that went with it. Perhaps on stage it sounded different, as most of the band seemed chuffed when we saw them later, but that's not where it matters - what matters is what the audience hear.
*sigh*
At least the one thing it did do was let me see the building. I can see us having a similar sound issue with the drum kit come the November concert. Hopefully I can convince the guy in charge, and the sound men that too loud is really not good. I hope they don't mic up our side drums. Even more relaxed drummers playing quieter won't help then.
Thank the goddess I'm not an official reviewer. Lets hope their reviewer was sitting in a better seat than me, and heard a better performance, or it would be an unfortunate downer for the bands I think.
- Posted using BlogPress from my iPad
Location:Aberdeen music hall